The resilience of the principle of proportionality. An eu directive would significantly facilitate the obligation for member states to comply with the proportionality principle and would guarantee that member states implement the proportionality test in an equivalent manner at all levels of regulation in order to avoid fragmentation of the single market. Jun 27, 2015 supreme court on eu and echr proportionality back to basics. According to the proportionality principle, no state or official or institution can interfere with an individuals rights under the european convention on human rights or under eu law, unless it is shown that the interference is justified. To speak of human rights in the twentyfirst century is to speak of proportionality.
The supreme court acknowledge that the court of justice is the only authoritative interpreter of the principle of proportionality in eu law and recognise that any attempt to identify general principles risks giving the impression that the cjeus approach is less nuanced and factsensitive than is actually the case. As a matter of fact, article 5 teu stipulates an obligation for the eu to respect the principle of proportionality when it exercises its competence. The principle of proportionality in european law, a. The principle of proportionality in the laws of europe. Pdf the principle of proportionality and european contract law. Proportionality has been received into the constitutional doctrine of courts in continental europe, the united kingdom, canada, new zealand, israel, south africa, and the united states, as well as the jurisprudence of treatybased legal systems such as the european convention on human rights. The supreme court acknowledge that the court of justice is the only authoritative interpreter of the principle of proportionality in eu law and recognise that any attempt to identify general principles risks giving the impression that the cjeus approach is less nuanced and. Ellis ed, the principle of proportionality in the laws of europe hart publishing, oxford 1999. In the eu it legitimizes the constitutional claims of eu law in the context of a multilevel legal system. The last step of the proportionality test, balancing of proportionality in its narrower sense, is analysed by means of the law of balancing. Does the chilean constitutional court use the proporc ionality test.
Proportionality is a general principle of eu law, enshrined in article 54 of the treaty on european union teu and reflected elsewhere in the eu treaties, for example in article 36 teu. This report examines two general principles of eu law, and one. The function of the proportionality principle in eu law. The principle of proportionality requires that there be a reasonable relationship between a particular objective to be achieved and the means used to achieve that objective.
The meaning of proportionality is examined in a number of different contexts, including those of ec law, the domestic law of the member states of the eu and the. This chapter focuses on proportionality as a device in international law and as an alternative model of law making. It first discusses proportionality as a form of legal control in armed conflict, the notion of proportionality in humanitarian law ius in bello, by itself and in its relations with the law governing the resort to the use of armed force ius ad bellum. The exact nature of the proportionality test that should be applied to eu and hra cases is also subject to confusion. Public law baraks proportionality is probably the most important and comprehensive book written on the subject to date. In this article i argue against the proportionality test in human rights adjudication. Edps guidelines on assessing the proportionality of measures. In this article the author assesses the proportionality principle in eu law from a legal theoretical and constitutional perspective with the aim of.
Eu proportionality test for regulated professions common set of. The concept of proportionality is used as a criterion of fairness and justice in statutory interpretation processes, especially in constitutional law, as a logical method to assist in discerning the correct balance between. Proportionality a german approach by yutaka araitakahashi this article briefly discusses the nature and character of the principle of proportionality in relation to administrative discretion in german public law. Member states to determine the rights and obligations of the parties in a way that the. One sees proportionality as a doctrinal tool that optimizes rights and public interests. In the former case, a manifestly disproportionate test is usually applied, while in the latter case, a least restrictive means test lrm is normally used. Aug 31, 2018 after outlining the general features of proportionality, the chapter illustrates the main concerns associated with proportionality in the internal market as regards a the risk of affecting the delicate structure of domestic constitutional systems through the restrictive effect on trade test, b the use of the fundamental rights and security discourses to promote the expansion of the. The author argues that its rigorous application is premised on germanys special historical context and.
Proportionality in the law of armed conflict oxford handbooks. Proportionality and the balancing of rights in the caselaw. The principle of proportionality in eu law richmond chambers. Kleiner white house report, hamilton project, both books, newest studies. The meaning of proportionality is examined in a number of different contexts, including those of ec law, the domestic law of the member states of the eu and the law of the european convention on human rights. Under the principle of proportionality, the content and form of union action shall not exceed what. A critique of proportionality by francisco urbina ssrn. Common set of criteria for an eu proportionality test for regulated professions. This test, i would suggest is not far off a proportionality test applied with some margin of discretion. The article focuses on the use the court might make of two particular elements of this test, that is, the test of suitability and the leastrestrictivemeans test. In other words, the principle of proportionality seeks to limit damage caused by military operations by requiring that the effects of the means and methods of warfare used must not be disproportionate to the military advantage sought.
This brief chapter explains the four subtests of the principle of proportionality and their role in rights reasoning. The other sees proportionality as allowing for openended moral reasoning. Childrens rights alliance legal doctrine of proportionality february 2007 page 2 of 4 proportionality as a principle of irish law ireland has for many years had concepts of reasonableness and equity in it jurisprudence, based on the wednesbury principle developed by the uk courts. In european union law there are generally acknowledged to be four stages to a proportionality test, namely. The european court of justice views proportionality as a general principle of eu law which regulates the. As lord steyn noted at 26 in r daly v secretary of state for justice ssj 2001 ukhl 26, proportionality is the appropriate test when rights. As the independent advisor to the eu institutions and bodies under regulation eu 17252018 on all matters concerning processing of personal data, the european data protection supervisor hereinafter, the edps intends to issue guidelines for assessing the proportionality of measures that limit the fundamental rights to privacy and to the protection of personal data hereinafter, the. These models are then applied to six comparative case studies in german and us constitutional law, the law of the european convention on human rights, european union law, world trade organization law, and international investment law.
The code of hammurabi, a babylonian law code dating from about 1722 bc, incorporated the principle of an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth. The introduction and development of this principle by the court of justice represents one of the most striking examples of the interaction between the community and national legal systems. In the context of fundamental rights, such as the right to the protection of personal data, proportionality is key for any limitation on these rights. The principle of proportionality if the above tests are met, how should the eu act. The third proportionality subtest is that of proportionality in the narrow sense. The author argues that its rigorous application is premised on. For that reason, this article proposes the introduction of the more classic threepart test of proportionality in the courts case law. Proportionality test before adoption of new regulation of.
In plain english it means that the eu should not get involved in matters which do not concern it. Structure of the proportionality test oxford scholarship. Article 1 each institution shall ensure constant respect for the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality, as laid down in article 5 of the treaty on european union. Under the principle of proportionality, the content and form of union action shall not exceed what is necessary to achieve the objectives of the treaties.
The concept of inverse proportionality can be contrasted with direct proportionality. Proportionality in germany in germany the principle of proportionality came into its own not in criminal law or law enforcement but in administrative law, when the police. The coming into force of the uk human rights act 1998 31 in 2000 has incorporated the european convention on human rights 32 into domestic english law and thus proportionality now plays a. And indeed interestingly, the concept of proportionality itself has been part of english law for centuries albeit that we all accept the modern concept derives from german law.
Consider two variables said to be inversely proportional to each other. Our posts are short comments on judgments and legislation and are intended for anyone who wishes to stay informed on eu law. Proportionality in the caselaw of the european court of human rights 5. The principle of proportionality started its triumphal march through human and constitutional rights law roughly a half century ago. If all other variables are held constant, the magnitude or absolute value of one inversely proportional variable decreases if the other variable increases, while their product the constant of proportionality k is always the same. Remember, the principle of proportionality applies in all fields of eu law. Lawyers and judges in england and wales must understand proportionality mainly because it is part and parcel of the jurisprudence of the strasbourg court.
Pnina alonshenker and guy davidov labour law research. Effectiveness, proportionality and legal certainty are the guiding principles in all our remedies cases. The famous weight formula, developed by alexy in his postscript to a theory of constitutional rights oup 2002 is then introduced and. But it only means that, as happens often, one and the same problem can be tackled from different angles. Note on the legal doctrine of proportionality february 2007.
Land hessen judgment of 9 november 2010, not yet published,1 the court of justice of the european union court of justice was called upon to balance the right. The principle of proportionality and subsidiarity is extremely important because it underlies everything the european union does in areas where it does not have the right of exclusive competence. Professor of public law, eu law, public international law and jurisprudence, university of hamburg. Proportionality test and balancing on a national and european level. Emiliou, the princple of proportionality in european law. In the relationship between the principle of proportionality and european contract law two dimensions can be distinguished.
Therefore, in the light of daly and alconbury the current position of proportionality in domestic common law is confused. It restricts authorities in the exercise of their powers by requiring them to strike a balance between the means used and the intended aim. Lord diplock, in the gchq case, reiterated these and labeled them procedural impropriety, illegality and irrationality. The principle of proportionality and the concept of margin. This article responds to mike taggarts bifurcation thesis and his argument that proportionality should be reserved for rightsbased cases. The institutions of the union shall apply the principle of proportionality as laid down in the protocol on the application of the principles of subsidiarity and. Iaa risk book chapter 16proportionality, materiality, etc. The book then offers an indepth analysis of the application and impact of the principle of proportionality in ec law. The doctrine is applied by both the ecthr and ecj, and so it has infiltrated uk law to a significant extent. The principle of proportionality and european contract law. I consider that the most important innovation in our remedies these last years has been a simplification push on our side for both mergers and antitrust, leading to greater effectiveness. The coming into force of the uk human rights act 1998 31 in 2000 has incorporated the european convention on human rights 32 into domestic english law and thus proportionality now plays a much more central role in the domestic context.
Constitutional rights and their limitations has positioned barak among the leading proponents of the received approach to human rights law. A longer description of the concepts application under european union law can be found in wikipedia, where it says. The principle of proportionality and the concept of margin of. Proportionality and the rule of law edited by grant huscroft. The modern procedural definition of the proportionality test is relatively clear. Proportionality has been described as meaning, in plain english, you must not use a steam hammer to crack a nut, if a nutcracker would do. This chapter focuses on proportionality as a device in international law and as an alternative model of lawmaking. Proportionality is a general principle in criminal law used to convey the idea that the severity of the punishment of an offender should fit the seriousness of the crime.
The principle of proportionality plays an important part in european union eu law and influenced english law through cases governed by eu law. The principle of proportionality ordains that administrative measures must not be drastic than is necessary for attaining the desired result. There have been statements of intention but not a full judicial ruling. In this regard, the principle of proportionality has become one of the cornerstones of the eu law and provided muchneeded clarification with regards the division of competences. This could include the drawing up of a code of conduct, the establishment of a list of relevant case law and the facilitation of information exchange between regulatory authorities. The principle of proportionality in english law constitutional administrative essay. A book of this type cannot of necessity provide an indepth account of the eu. Supreme court on eu and echr proportionality back to basics.
The application of proportionality in the eu differs based on whether eu legal acts or legal acts of the member states are concerned. The proportionality test in uk administrative law a new. After outlining the general features of proportionality, the chapter illustrates the main concerns associated with proportionality in the internal market as regards a the risk of affecting the delicate structure of domestic constitutional systems through the restrictive effect on trade test, b the use of the fundamental rights and security discourses to promote the expansion of the. Nicholas emiliou, the principle of proportionality in european law. Nov 11, 2012 in this article i argue against the proportionality test in human rights adjudication. The european law blog aims to highlight, and comment on, current developments in eu case law and legislation.
58 1275 1422 424 65 555 232 336 856 665 117 1298 1045 998 1087 781 88 1303 1487 519 218 325 1513 1607 1084 514 955 1123 691 1389 113 1145 433 992 1240 810 1055 1179 395 234 124 238 1271 913 723